Our Rating:
4.6
Amana Washing Machine (NTW4516FW) Review
Best Budget
Washer of 2025!
Authors: Nicole R, Anna N, Jacob P, Tommy G
Introduction
The Amana washer (NTW4516FW) proves that simple, dependable cleaning and a tight budget can live in the same laundry room. After weeks of everyday loads, muddy weekend gear, towels, and bedding, we came away impressed by how confidently this traditional top load agitator washer checks the right boxes for its price point!
This washer sidesteps the trend of digital touchscreens and overly complex cycles, instead doubling down on the core mechanics that have been proven to work for decades. You get straightforward controls, real scrubbing power, and enough flexibility to handle busy households without paying for bells and whistles you will never use. It is an amazing value for shoppers who want function first and are comfortable with a few thoughtful trade-offs that keep the cost within reach!
Design
The Amana NTW4516FW is a shining example of purpose-driven engineering, where every element is designed to maximize cleaning performance and durability for its price point.
​
-
Form Factor: This washer proudly sports a classic, utilitarian design with a raised back panel and a clean white finish. It doesn’t pretend to be a futuristic statement piece; it’s an appliance built to work hard. The solid, opaque metal lid is sturdy and forgoes a glass window or soft-close hinge, which are thoughtful omissions that trim costs without impacting the machine’s primary function in any way.
-
Rotary Dials: In an age of often confusing digital menus, the tactile satisfaction of turning a physical dial is a welcome return to simplicity. The controls are immediately understandable, allowing you to select your cycle, water level, and temperature with a confident click. During our daily use, we found this direct, no-nonsense interface to be a breath of fresh air, eliminating any guesswork.
-
Porcelain-Coated Steel Tub: At the heart of the machine is a durable porcelain-coated steel wash basket. This material provides a smooth, snag-free surface that is gentle on fabrics, from rugged denim to delicate sweaters. While more expensive models may feature full stainless steel, the porcelain finish offers excellent protection and longevity, representing a smart balance of quality and cost-effectiveness that is perfect for a budget-focused model.
-
American Assembly: The washer is designed, engineered, and assembled in the U.S.A., a point of pride that speaks to a commitment to domestic manufacturing. This adds an extra layer of confidence in the machine's construction and quality control.
Washing Performance
The Amana’s performance is defined by its powerful and effective approach to the fundamentals of washing clothes, prioritizing deep cleaning over unnecessary frills.
​
-
Dual-Action Agitator: This is the machine's star player. Unlike the impellers found in many modern machines, this traditional dual-action agitator provides a robust and thorough clean. The top auger pulls clothes down to the bottom of the tub, where the lower portion provides aggressive mechanical action to scrub out dirt and stains. We found its cleaning power to be impressive, easily handling heavily soiled work clothes and ground-in dirt that other machines can struggle with. For families, this feature alone is a massive selling point.
-
Deep Water Wash Option: This feature directly addresses the most common complaint with modern high-efficiency washers: low water levels. While the machine does have an auto-sensing feature for everyday loads, the Deep Water Wash option allows you to fill the tub with the maximum amount of water. In our testing, we discovered the key is to pair this option with cycles like "Bulky/Sheets" to guarantee a deep soak for your dirtiest loads, ensuring every item is fully saturated for a powerful clean.
-
Cycle Selection: With 8 distinct wash cycles, the NTW4516FW covers all the essential bases. The "Delicates" cycle provides a gentle touch with a slower spin, while the "Bulky/Sheets" cycle is perfect for larger items. This curated selection avoids the overwhelming and often redundant options on pricier machines, giving you exactly what you need for everyday laundry tasks.
User Experience
The Amana NTW4516FW makes deliberate choices to streamline its operation, focusing on features that add real-world value while omitting those that would needlessly inflate its cost.
​
-
Late Lid Lock: This is a small but brilliant feature that adds a surprising amount of convenience. It allows you to pause the cycle and add a forgotten sock or t-shirt long after the wash has begun. We used this feature more times than we can count, and it’s a practical perk that makes laundry day just a little bit easier.
-
No Fabric Softener Dispenser: This is the most significant compromise the machine makes, and it is a clear, intentional choice to deliver such amazing value. The washer does not have a built-in, automatic dispenser for liquid fabric softener. To use softener, you must either add it manually during the rinse cycle or use a dispenser ball, like a Downy Ball. While a minor inconvenience, forgoing this single component allows Amana to offer a machine with a powerful agitator and robust build at a fantastic price point. It’s a trade-off that we feel is more than fair.
-
The Trade-Off: The machine’s maximum spin speed of 680 RPM is lower than that of premium models. This means clothes may come out slightly damper, requiring a bit more time in the dryer. However, this is a common characteristic of budget-friendly washers and has a hidden benefit: the slower spin is inherently gentler on fabrics, which can help extend the life of your clothes over time.
Reliability & Value
Living with the Amana washer day-to-day reveals a machine that is a reliable workhorse, built with an understanding of what matters for long-term value.
​​
-
Noise Level: For a machine with such a powerful agitator, we found its operation to be reasonably quiet. You will hear it working—the clicks of the cycle advancing and the swish of the agitator are the sounds of a machine getting the job done—but it is far from disruptive. As with any washer, ensuring the load is balanced is key to a smooth and quiet spin cycle.
-
Cycle Duration: Modern efficiency standards mean that cycle times, even on a traditional-style machine, can be longer than you might remember from older models, often running for about an hour. This is due to the sensing and balancing phases that ensure an effective and efficient wash. We quickly adjusted to this and found the results were well worth the time.
-
Built for Value, Not Excess: It’s important to approach a budget appliance with the right expectations. To achieve this incredible price point, the Amana NTW4516FW is not over-engineered with the premium, costly components found in machines that sell for two or three times as much. This is a deliberate design philosophy focused on providing fantastic performance for a reasonable lifespan. Our hands-on experience gives us confidence that for the average household, it represents a superb balance of performance, durability, and cost.
Conclusion: Best Budget Pick!
The Amana NTW4516FW earns its place as our best budget washing machine of 2025 because it nails the fundamentals. It cleans thoroughly, operates with refreshingly simple controls, and gives you useful choices like deep water fill when you want a more traditional wash feel!
The compromises are plain and reasonable for a cost conscious design. You give up a built in fabric softener dispenser, premium finishes, and the fastest spin extraction to keep the price within reach, and you gain a washer that focuses on the one thing that matters most, getting clothes clean with minimal fuss. For its price point, it delivers amazing value, and with basic care and thoughtful use, it is a smart pick for households that want dependable results without overspending!
🎉🎉🎉